The Hills Have Eyes (2006 Film Review)
Directed by: Alexandre Aja; Written by: Alexandre Aja and Grégory Levasseur
Starring: Aaron Stanford, Kathleen Quinlan, Vinessa Shaw, Emilie de Ravin, Dan Byrd, Robert Joy, and Ted Levine
MPAA Rating:R; Running Time: 106 Minutes
The Nicsperiment Score: 8/10
The Carters are headed across country with their RV to San Diego. Patriarch, Bob, along with his wife, teenaged son and daughter, adult daughter and son-in-law, grandbaby, and two German Shepherds are cutting across a vast swath of desert when they take a recommended shortcut on a dirt road to their doom. While crossing a desolate stretch which once housed nuclear test sites, the Carters are ambushed by a mutated, psychotic family that assault and eat them. Only a few Carters survive the initial attack. Now they must fight for their lives.
Horror remakes sprang into existence shortly after the genre itself did. Even so, 2006 seems to have hosted more major release horror remakes than almost any other year. Some are certainly better than others. The Hills Have Eyes should have no business in that higher tier, but it's not only arguably the best horror remake of 2006, but possibly better than the 1977 Wes Craven original.
1977's The Hills Have Eyes is a fairly simple film. Wes Craven tried to inject some political statements into the original as he did in several of his films. He might have been the master of horror, but his champagne socialist views were laughable, a guy with a house in the Hollywood Hills and multiple homes in Martha's Vineyard raging against the middle class. The political side of his The Hills Have Eyes falls flat, as he inadvertently makes his middle class characters rootable heroes against their horrific, inbred, cannibalistic foes. Alexandre Aja, the French director of this 2006 remake, largely leaves politics at the door, other than a gnarly and frankly awesome shot of one of the heroes javelining an American flag-tipped spear into a bad guy's throat. This is, quite simply, an extremely heightened and gritty survivor horror film that puts genre shocks and thrills above all else, to its great benefit.
The Hills Have Eyes remake largely follows the plot-points of the original film, but recasts the bad guys as nuclear mutated freaks. It's a fun spin that gives the remake a different tone and aesthetic. This also gives the filmmakers an opportunity to go all out with the villain design, and the makeup and effects here are disgustingly top notch. The film is shot beautifully, or at least the parched desert and mutated grime and gore look fantastic and are lit just right. The acting is also phenomenal. Like the original, this remake falls into the "wimpy, civilized guy has to become a hyper-masculine chad to survive and save his loved ones" subgenre (think Straw Dogs). Without spoiling his final fate, Aaron Stanford's son-in-law character is as limp and vanilla pudding as possible, but when the switch finally flips, it's an absolutely rousing moment. I went from yelling at the screen that he stop being a word I don't like to use here to enthusiastically cheering him on. Stanford played the boyish Pyro in X2 just three years before this, but he completely transforms into this role to a point that he's completely unrecognizable, and makes for a surprisingly great hero.
Indeed, the greatest surprise here is that a French director, and especially THIS French director given his previous work, co-wrote and directed a film with THIS third act. Yes, the mid-film ambush scene is one of the darkest, most chaotic, and most harrowing and disturbing scenes in all of 00's cinema, but the last 30 minutes are absolutely fist-pumping, and contain a couple moments of shocking heroism and anti-nihilism. Not too many films with this much gritty, visceral, and disturbing violence are able to also pull off this kind of final act. It's extreme, but...it's extreme. Kudos to Aja. 2006's The Hills Have Eyes just might be a horror classic!


Comments
It is interesting how a remake can outshine the original by leaning harder into the horror.